Etsy vs Shopify POD: Which Pays More in 2026?

Compare Etsy vs Shopify print-on-demand fees and profits. Real numbers show which platform keeps more of your revenue in 2026.

Choosing between Etsy and Shopify for your print-on-demand (POD) store isn’t just about traffic—it’s about profit. In 2026, fees and platform costs eat into your revenue differently. If you’re selling $25 shirts or $40 hoodies, the difference between platforms could mean thousands per year. Here’s the exact breakdown of what you’ll pay—and keep—on each.

Which platform costs less per sale: Etsy or Shopify?

Etsy charges $2.90 per sale on a $25 item. Shopify charges 2.9% + $0.30 per sale, but you pay 0% if you use Shopify Payments.

How much does Shopify’s monthly fee affect profit?

Shopify’s cheapest plan is $29/month. Etsy has no monthly fee but charges $0.20 per listing (renewed every 4 months).

• •If you sell 100 items/month on Shopify Basic, your $29 fee costs $0.29 per sale.
• •On Etsy, 100 listings cost $5/year ($0.20 x 25 listings renewed every 4 months).
• •For 200 sales/month, Shopify’s $29 fee drops to $0.15 per sale, while Etsy’s cost stays $0.025 per sale.
• •Shopify becomes cheaper per sale once you hit ~150 sales/month.

What are the real print costs for POD products?

Print-on-demand costs are the same on both platforms. Printful, Printify, and Gelato have similar base prices.

How much profit do you make on a $25 shirt?

Profit depends on platform fees and production costs. Here’s the exact breakdown for a $25 black unisex t-shirt in 2026.

Does Shopify’s $29/month plan ever make sense for POD?

Yes, but only if you sell enough. Shopify becomes more profitable than Etsy once you exceed ~150 sales/month.

• •At 50 sales/month, Etsy keeps $145 more in your pocket ($2.90 vs $1.32 in fees).
• •At 150 sales/month, Shopify’s $29 fee is offset by lower per-sale costs, saving you $105 vs Etsy.
• •At 300 sales/month, Shopify saves you $315 vs Etsy.
• •Shopify’s advantage grows as your volume increases because Etsy’s fees scale with sales.

Which platform brings more traffic for POD stores?

Etsy has built-in traffic. Shopify requires you to drive all your own visitors.

• •Etsy gets ~81 million monthly visitors searching for handmade/print-on-demand products.
• •Shopify stores rely on paid ads (Facebook, Google, TikTok) or organic SEO, which costs $0.50–$3 per click.
• •Organic traffic to a Shopify store takes 6–12 months to build, while Etsy listings can rank immediately.
• •If you’re just starting, Etsy’s traffic can offset its lower profit margins.

Is it worth paying for Shopify Plus for POD in 2026?

No. Shopify Plus costs $2,300/month and is overkill for POD sellers.

• •Shopify Plus offers 0% transaction fees, but you’d need to sell ~80,000 items/month to justify the cost.
• •Most POD sellers max out at Shopify Basic or Shopify ($79/month).
• •The $29/month plan covers 95% of POD sellers’ needs.
• •Unless you’re scaling to 7-figures, stick with Basic or Standard.

How do taxes and refunds affect profit on each platform?

Taxes and refunds reduce profit on both platforms, but the impact differs due to their fee structures.

Which platform is better for long-term POD growth?

Shopify is better for long-term growth, but Etsy is easier to start.

• •Shopify lets you build a brand with a custom domain, email marketing, and upsells.
• •Etsy keeps you in their ecosystem, making it harder to transition to a standalone store later.
• •Shopify’s lower fees scale with volume, while Etsy’s fees eat into profits as you grow.
• •If you plan to expand beyond POD (e.g., digital products, merch bundles), Shopify is the better choice.

What’s the best real-world example comparing both?

A seller moving 500 units/month on Etsy vs Shopify shows a $3,000/year difference in profit.

Related Articles